Book a virtual one-on-one session with an information expert and get help with research, papers, and projects.
Knowing the distinction between scholarly, popular, and trade sources is an important step for any student. Using scholarly sources in your research ensures that your papers have academic merit and are often backed by actual studies and work that has peer reviewed by professionals in the field. This does not mean that popular and trade sources do not have their merits.
Scholarly sources such as journals, academic books, and dissertations, undergo a formal evaluation process before publication. This helps to ensure high-quality information and accuracy of results. They are written by experts in their particular field and are often affiliated with colleges, universities, or research centers. Note that scholarly sources are not always peer-reviewed.
Characteristics of scholarly studies:
Trade publications, or professional magazines, are written by staff writers or practitioners in a given trade or profession. These publications tend to publish news, statistics, trends and other information relevant to their industry. Most trade publications do not undergo a peer-review process; however, there are exceptions.
Characteristics of trade source articles:
Popular sources such as magazines and newspapers do not typically go through the same review process as scholarly resources; in many cases, popular resources are reviewed by a single editor, who may or may not have expertise in the subject area. Popular resources are usually written for a broad audience and, as a result, tend to have little depth on the subject matter. The purpose of these sources is to entertain and sell more copies of their magazines.
Characteristics of popular source articles:
The following video from Vanderbilt University reviews the differences between scholarly and popular periodicals.